Do crippled birds count toward the daily bag limit?

Fetchin' up California hunting laws and rules.What do you think?

Should crippled birds count toward your daily bag limit, even if you made every effort to retrieve it?

Carrie Wilson, a marine biologist and spokesperson for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), claims “ethical hunters” always count crippled birds toward their bag limits because it’s the right thing to do “even when they think no one’s looking.”  She contends that the regulations are silent on the matter.

As a lawyer and avid hunter, I respectfully disagree. Here’s why.

The regulations address this issue head on. Under federal law, to “bag” a bird means that it has been reduced to the hunter’s possession.  A  “daily bag limit” is the maximum number of birds or species of birds allowed to be taken per day in a particular area.  Under California law, a “bag and possession limit” is the daily bag limit that “may be taken and possessed by any one person unless otherwise authorized.”

One might argue that I’m focusing on the law and ignoring ethics, but the law also addresses the only ethical issue I see here.  Under federal and California law, it’s illegal (and in my opinion, unethical) to sail a bird and neglect to make a “reasonable effort” to find it. In fact, nothing get’s my blood boiling more than seeing hunter’s crip birds and not look for them.

Most everyone has heard the saying, “A bird in hand is worth two in the bush.”  Crippled birds can be extremely difficult–if not impossible–to locate.  Ethical hunters do the best they can to find them.  That’s one reason I always take along my Labrador Retriever.


About Legal Labrador

Legal Labrador is an advocate for and defender of California hunters’ rights. We provide legal support to all interested parties within the hunting industry, including Legal Labrador members, individual hunters, fish and game authorities, hunting organizations, and service providers. Legal Labrador consolidates and summarizes federal, state, and local hunting laws. Our California hunters’ rights attorney is here to provide legal advice and, if necessary, representation to hunters cited with hunting violations.
This entry was posted in Daily Bag Limits, Migratory game birds, Possession Limits, Resident game birds, Upland Game Birds and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Make a suggestion for this page

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s